Talk:Rifle

I have mixed feelings on the reorganization of this page. Yes, it's good to distinguish crafted from looted/rewarded weapons... but is that distinction necessary at the topmost level? Or was it enough to simply state "No schematic (insert reason here)" for each of the entries? I'm not sure. We should think about this page from the average user's point of view. Which would the average visitor value more highly: a single sorted list of all rifles in the game, or two sorted lists of rifles, one of crafted weapons and the other of looted/quest weapons? It's hard to say. Thoughts? --Influenza 22:59, 16 Aug 2005 (CEST)


 * I like em because I always want to know what I can buy and what I have to loot. If you don't like it I will change it back however.


 * Let's give it a few days for other people to comment. No need to undo all that work just yet :). And as a final request, please end all your comments on Talk pages with this: --~ . That will automatically leave your name and the time of your post at the end of your comment, like this: --Influenza 23:19, 16 Aug 2005 (CEST)

I like em because I always want to know what I can buy and what I have to loot. If you don't like it I will change it back however. The ideal here is to get the information fast. Without any sort of organization, just a generic listing of the stuff, I got frustrated and went to another site. --Careos 23:21, 16 Aug 2005 (CEST)


 * Ive been thinking about this for a while and although not very beautiful in form, I am the one who always tend to say: Form follows function., so Im with Careos. If you get to know something about a new rifle, first question is always: Where did you get that? or translated, is it a quest reward/loot or can I bother my WS of choice with a request? Idealy you would have a short table sorting them all into incaftable/looted/ - energy/kinetic - lvl and skill requierments, but somehow I feel that might be an overkill. --5C0UT 10:45, 17 Aug 2005 (CEST)
 * Separating weaponsmith weapons and quest/loot weapons seems ideal, to me. It's quite clear in the table of contents.  We should just clarify whether the non-weaponsmith weapons are granted directly by a quest/loot, or if a schematic is looted.  Just like the crafters apron, it might not be a schematic you can learn, but you might still have to craft it.--Tandalo 11:16, 17 Aug 2005 (CEST)